Uncertain Warriors
Lyndon Johnson and His Vietnam Advisors
David M. Barrett
xii, 248 pages, illustrated, 6 x 9
Modern War Studies
Paper ISBN 978-0-7006-0631-3, $15.95
Lyndon Johnson, when it comes
to his role in the Vietnam War, is popularly portrayed as an
irrational "hawkish" leader who bullied hi advisers
and refused to solicit a wide range of opinions. that depiction,
David Barrett argues, is simplistic and far from accurate.
In this book, Barrett contends that Johnson's insistence on
secrecy, plus his colorful personality, have overshadowed his
approach to policymaking and his consideration of a wide spectrum
of opinion from a variety of formal and informal advisers. Following
a paper trail of memoranda, letters, diaries, and notes, Barrett
not only examines how Johnson dealt with his advisers and developed
a complex system of consultation but delves into Johnson's personality
and style to show their impact on his decisions.
Despite Johnson's willingness to consider opposing viewpoints,
Barrett concedes, his rational advisory system nevertheless produced
a flawed and fatal set of policies because they were based on
an increasingly outdated world view.
"A book that should be read closely by those interested
in LBJ and why Vietnam happened. . . . By allowing for a very
complex LBJ, Barrett has given us a more interesting figure than
have many better-known books."--Deborah Shapley,
author of Promise and Power: The Life and Times of Robert
McNamara
"A book of great humanity and compassion. . . . Fair-minded
without being uncritical, thorough but never pedantic, always
clear and readable, this book belongs on the small shelf of truly
first-class books on American policy in the Vietnam War."--William
P. Bundy, former editor of Foreign Affairs
"A genuinely important study which views President Johnson's
conduct of Vietnam policy with a fresh eye."--George
McT. Kahin, author of Intervention: How America Became
Involved in Vietnam
"Uncertain Warriors will be much discussed as
Vietnam scholars continue to debate the question, 'Why Vietnam?'"--Lloyd
Gardner, author of Approaching Vietnam: From World War
II through Dienbienphu
"The best account I have seen of Tet decisions."--George
C. Herring, author of America's Longest War: The United
States and Vietnam, 19501975
"Highly recommended."--Library Journal
DAVID M. BARRETT is assistant professor of political
science at Villanova University.
|