Moral Anatomy and Moral Reasoning
Robert V. Hannaford
208 pages, 6 x 9
Cloth ISBN 978-0-7006-0607-8, $29.95
Robert Hannaford's book answers
two fundamental questions: How do we come to do what is morally
demanded of us--i.e., what compels us into "acceptable acts"?
And, how does our being moral emerge from what we are and how
we are related to each other?
Hannaford shows that doing (reasoning and acting morally)
and being (our "moral anatomy" or essential
nature) do not exist in a vacuum but are rooted in community,
in our relations with others. Moral reasoning, he argues, focuses
on what we ought to do in a situation where we must consider
the needs, desires, and expectations of others. "It's about
doing," he explains. "We provide food and water for
the victims of an urban riot or a nearby natural disaster, and
when we are met by a lost child, we try to help it in finding
its parents. As responsible people we [make] choices that we
believe can be shown to be acceptable to others in the community.
What is morally correct must reflect the judgment of the moral
community."
Rejecting relativists who claim the impossibility of universal
moral values, Hannaford develops a theory based on a variation
of the Golden Rule. He demonstrates how our natural responsiveness
to others' feelings and sufferings, our concern for other persons
"conceived as like ourselves" lies at the heart of
our moral anatomy and moral reasoning and ultimately guides our
moral actions.
"A dazzling and, at times, masterful display of common
sense in moral philosophy. This is a work of genuine philosophical
vision that has both power and depth of insight. It brings together
and brings to bear upon one another a wealth of insights about
the human condition-displaying the right sort of sensitivities
to matters at nearly every juncture."--Laurence Thomas,
author of Living Morally: A Psychology of Moral Character
"The broad sweep of the author's argument moves the discussion
of moral motivation beyond the old debates about philosophical
egoism into such contemporary contexts as the inherently interpersonal
character of human language and the inevitably trans-cultural
presuppositions of moral evaluations between cultures."--Thomas
Wren, author of Caring about Morality: Philosophical Perspectives
in Moral Psychology
"This is a penetrating analysis of why attempts to explain
moral reasoning in terms of what rationally self-interested individuals
can publicly advocate are bound to fail. Instead, Hannaford introduces
the notion of 'moral anatomy,' which places moral reasoning within
the network of socially oriented attitudes, motives, and interpersonal
relationships that make sense of who we are as persons and as
members of moral communities. He effectively supports his thesis
by showing that even in very early childhood, our emerging moral
anatomy reveals moral reasoning at work."--Michael S.
Pritchard, author of On Becoming Responsible
ROBERT HANNAFORD is professor of philosophy at Ripon
College in Ripon, Wisconsin. He is editor of Concept Formation
and the Explanation of Behavior.
|