The Vietnam War Files
Uncovering the Secret History of Nixon-Era Strategy
Jeffrey Kimball
November 2003
384 pages, 15 illustrations, 3 maps, 6-1/8 x 9-1/4
Modern War Studies
Cloth ISBN 978-0-7006-1283-3, $34.95
WINNER OF THE LINK-KUEHL PRIZE, GIVEN BY THE SOCIETY FOR HISTORIANS OF AMERICAN FOREIGN RELATIONS
How
Richard Nixon and Henry Kissinger pursued their public vow to end
the Vietnam War and win the peace has long been entangled in bitter
controversy and obscured by political spin. Recent declassifications
of archival documents, on both sides of the former Iron and Bamboo
Curtains, have at last made it possible to uncover the truth behind
Nixons and Kissingers management of the war and to better
understand the policies and strategies of the Vietnamese, Soviets,
and Chinese.
Drawing from this treasure trove of formerly secret files, Jeffrey
Kimball has excerpted more than 140 print documents and taped White
House conversations bearing on Nixon-era strategy. Most of these
have never before been published and many provide smoking-gun evidence
on such long-standing controversies as the madman theory
and the decent-interval option. They reveal that by
1970 Nixons and Kissingers madman and détente
strategies had fallen far short of frightening the North Vietnamese
into making concessions. By 1971, as Kissinger notes in one key
document, the administration had decided to withdraw the remaining
U.S. combat troops while creating a healthy interval for South
Vietnams fate to unfold.
The new evidence uncovers a number of behind-the-scenes ployssuch
as Nixons secret nuclear alert of October 1969and sheds
more light on Nixons goals in Vietnam and his and Kissingers
strategies of Vietnamization, the China card, and triangular
diplomacy. The excerpted documents also reveal significant
new information about the purposes of the LINEBACKER bombings, Nixons
manipulation of the POW issue, and the conduct of the secret negotiations
in Parisas well as other key topics, events, and issues. All
of these are effectively framed by Kimball, whose introductions
to each document provide insightful historical context.
Building on the ground-breaking arguments of his earlier prize-winning
book, Nixons Vietnam War, Kimball also offers readers
a concise narrative of the evolution of Nixon-era strategy and a
critical assessment of historical myths about the war. The story
that emerges from both the documents and Kimballs contextual
narratives directly contradicts the Nixon-Kissinger version of events.
In fact, they did not pursue a consistent strategy from beginning
to end and did not win a peace with honor.
"In a superb archival account, Kimball, author of the widely
praised Nixon's Vietnam War skillfully discredits [the
accounts in] Nixon's and Kissinger's memoirs and produces both
U.S. and North Vietnamese documents that expose their reactive
and often frenetic style of policy making. Indeed, Nixon's 'Madman
Theory' is given new meaning by Kimball's examination of the nuclear
alert of October 1969. . . . As for South Vietnam, Kimball produces
documents that prove neither Nixon nor Kissinger harbored any
illustions concerning Saigon's chances for survival. In the end,
despite their bluster, Nixon and Kissinger agreed to terms in
1973 that they could have obtained in 1969. The 'decent interval'
was neither decent nor sufficient to save Saigon. Essential."--Choice
A quite remarkable and highly readable account of the Nixon
Administrations war and peace strategy. The variety of sources,
the clear and concise introductions, and the drama itself of how
the Madman Theory evolved, and dissolved, make this
our best study yet of the wars end.--Lloyd C. Gardner,
author of Pay Any Price: Lyndon Johnson and the Wars for Vietnam
An important book, full of new and essential material,
tied together by Kimballs exceedingly clear prose and judicious
evaluations. Students of the era will be in his debt for a long
time to come.--Melvin Small, author of The Presidency
of Richard Nixon
JEFFREY KIMBALL is professor of history at Miami University
and the author of To Reason Why: The Debate about the Causes
of U.S. Involvement in the Vietnam War and Nixons Vietnam
War, winner of the Robert H. Ferrell Book Prize.
|