Postmodern Philosophy and Law
Douglas E. Litowitz
240 pages, 6-1/8 x 9-1/4
Cloth ISBN 978-0-7006-0857-7, $35.00
Paper ISBN 978-0-7006-0999-4, $15.95
Now that contemporary scholars
have begun to extend postmodern theory to law, an appraisal of
its relevance in that sphere is especially important. This book
offers a critical introduction to writings on law by key postmodern
philosophers--Nietzsche, Foucault, Derrida, Lyotard, and Rorty--and
articulates the strengths and weaknesses of postmodern legal
theory.
Douglas Litowitz takes a critical stance on these thinkers
and determines that postmodern philosophy falls short of a positive
jurisprudence--a vision of a just state and a moral legal system--because
it takes an unduly external perspective on the law and espouses
an unworkable anti-foundationalism. The postmodernist perspective,
he argues, is too removed from our legal practices to resolve
legal problems like abortion, flag burning, or pornography.
Litowitz shows that postmodernism is so far removed from the
language games in which lawyers and judges decide key legal issues
that it leaves the internal practice of law untouched, and its
radical rejection of foundations precludes a position from which
a just legal system might be built. Still, postmodernism can
make a significant contribution to legal theory by showing the
limits of existing arrangements, focusing attention on genealogy
and discourse, and empowering those who have been denied a voice
under the legal system.
Postmodern Philosophy and Law bridges the gap between
Anglo-American jurisprudence and postmodern theory by discussing
not only traditional approaches such as natural law theory and
legal positivism but also continental philosophy and critical
legal studies. It is the first book to expound and critique postmodern
legal theory and its ramifications for a mainstream audience
of legal scholars and philosophers.
"Under Litowitz's direction, the journey into postmodern
legal theory is understandable, focused, and clear. Anyone wanting
an introduction to postmodernism and legal theory should begin
with this well written and engaging book. Highly recommended."--Choice
"An important contribution. Litowitz offers a very readable
and understandable analysis of a rather difficult group of postmodern
writers and theorists. This book will be of great value to scholars
as well as those who are beginning the study of legal theory
and jurisprudence."--Gary Minda, author of Postmodern
Legal Movements: Law and Jurisprudence at Century's End
DOUGLAS E. LITOWITZ is visiting assistant professor
at Chicago-Kent College of Law.
|