Joseph E. Johnston and the Defense of Richmond
Steven H. Newton
288 pages, 6 x 9
Modern War Studies
Cloth ISBN 978-0-7006-0921-5, $29.95 (t)
Most often viewed as a prelude
to Robert E. Lee's Civil War victories of 1862, Joseph E. Johnston's
campaign in Virginia early that year has been considered uninspired
at best, catastrophic at worst. Steven Newton now offers a revisionist
account of Johnston's operations between the York and James Rivers
to show how his performance in the "Peninsular War"
contributed to a crucial strategic victory for the Confederacy.
Newton acknowledges the limitations usually attributed to
Johnston by other historians but suggests that assessments of
the general's performance in Virginia have been colored by later
controversies. He argues that contemporary sources portray Johnston
as conducting his operations competently and within the strategic
framework laid down in Richmond, even when he personally disagreed
with those decisions. By holding his outnumbered army together
and delaying the advance of Union forces, the general bought
critical time for the Confederacy to recruit, organize, and arm
the expanded army that would drive the Federals away from Richmond
soon after Johnston himself was wounded at Seven Pines.
Focusing on the period between mid-February and late May 1862,
Newton examines in detail the high-level conferences in Richmond
to set strategy and the relationship of the Peninsula campaign
to operations in the Shenandoah Valley and the western Confederacy.
What emerges is a portrait of a general who was much more complex
in thought and action than even his advocates have argued. By
examining what Johnston actually accomplished rather than speculating
on what he might have done, Newton shows that his overall conduct
of the campaign holds up well under scrutiny.
Marked by painstaking research and analysis, Newton's reconsideration
of Johnston is a key account of Confederate operations in the
pivotal eastern Virginia theater in 1862. It provides an important
new look at an episode in the war that until now has received
little attention and helps rescue an unduly maligned leader from
the shadow of Lee.
"A challenging new assessment of Joe Johnston's conduct
of the defense of Richmond and an important contribution to the
scholarly debate about Civil War military leadership. No serious
student of the war can overlook Newton's careful research and
provocative conclusions."--Craig L. Symonds, author
of Stonewall of the West
"This is by far the best thing I know of on the war in
Virginia in the first five months of 1862. I have learned a lot
from Newton's work and I recommend it very strongly."--Richard
M. McMurry, author of Two Great Rebel Armies
"An impressive, invaluable, and bracingly revisionist
account of Johnston's service in Virginia."--Steven E.
Woodworth, author of Davis and Lee at War
STEVEN H. NEWTON is associate professor of history
at Delaware State University and the author of The Battle
of Seven Pines.
|